October 11, 2007

Plagiarism? No, we're just borrowing better English - Correspondance: NATURE

Ihsan Yilmaz1
The accusations made by arXiv that my colleagues and I have plagiarized the works of others, reported in your News story 'Turkish physicists face accusations of plagiarism' (Nature 449, 8; doi:10.1038/449008b 2007) are upsetting and unfair.
It's inappropriate to single out my colleagues and myself on this issue. For those of us whose mother tongue is not English, using beautiful sentences from other studies on the same subject in our introductions is not unusual. I imagine that if all articles from specialist fields of research were checked, similarities with other texts and papers would easily be found. In my case, I aimed to cite all the references from which I had sourced information, although I may have missed some of them.
Borrowing sentences in the part of a paper that simply helps to better introduce the problem should not be seen as plagiarism. Even if our introductions are not entirely original, our results are — and these are the most important part of any scientific paper.
In the current climate of 'publish or perish', we are under pressure to publish our findings along with an introduction that reads well enough for the paper to be published and read, so that our research will be noticed and inspire further work.

Random Posts


  • Misconduct, Not Error, Found Behind Most Journal Retractions - THE CHRONICLE

    Paul BaskenResearch misconduct, rather than error, is the leading cause of retractions in scientific journals, with the problem especially pronounced in more prestigious publications, a comprehensive analysis has concluded. The analysis, described on Monday in PNAS, the Proceedings of the National... READ MORE>>

  • Plagiarism in Turkey - Copy, Shake, and Paste

    Some Turkish academics have been very busy the past few months, it seems. Perhaps inspired by the VroniPlag Wiki documentation in Germany, the authors have put together a massive documentation of plagiarism in Turkish theses that A. Murat Eren, a computer science Ph.D. and post-doc researcher i... READ MORE>>

  • Mathgen paper accepted!

    Nate Eldredge I’m pleased to announce that Mathgen has had its first randomly-generated paper accepted by a reputable journal! On August 3, 2012, a certain Professor Marcie Rathke of the University of Southern North Dakota at Hoople submitted a very interesting article to Advances in Pure M... READ MORE>>

  • False positives: fraud and misconduct are threatening scientific research - The Guardian

    Alok Jha Dirk Smeesters had spent several years of his career as a social psychologist at Erasmus University in Rotterdam studying how consumers behaved in different situations. Did colour have an effect on what they bought? How did death-related stories in the media affect how people picked produc... READ MORE>>

  • How Plagiarism Happens - The Atlantic

     Ta-Nehisi CoatesWhen Fareed Zakaria was caught plagiarizing Jill Lepore, he offered the same defense that almost every person caught plagiarizing offers:The mistake, he said, occurred when he confused the notes he had taken about Ms. Lepore's article -- he said he often w... READ MORE>>

  • At Islamic varsity, you must be a plagiarist to catch one - The Express Tribune

    Peer Muhammad A professor at IIUI, who was found to have plagiarised, has been made the head of a committee that examines plagiarism cases.Dr Muhammad Sher, a professor of computer science at the International Islamic University Islamabad, was recently promoted to be the dean of Faculty of Basic... READ MORE>>

  • Viewpoint: The spectre of plagiarism haunting Europe - BBC NEWS

    Debora Weber-Wulff  Professor of Media and Computing, University of Applied Sciences, Berlin A spectre is haunting Europe, and this time it is the spectre of plagiarism and scientific misconduct. Some high-profile politicians have had to resign in the last 18 months - but the revelations ar... READ MORE>>

.

.
.

Popular Posts