October 11, 2007

Plagiarism: text-matching program offers an answer - Correspondance: NATURE

John Bechhoefer1
The removal of almost 70 papers from the arXiv server on suspicion of plagiarism is dismaying (Nature 449, 8; doi:10.1038/449008b 2007). But, in a similar way to that currently being tested by the cooperative group of publishers CrossRef ('Academic accused of living on borrowed lines' Nature 448, 632–633; doi:10.1038/448632b 2007), the search technology that led to this removal could be used to reduce future problems.
Every paper submitted to arXiv could be examined by a search engine that looks for overlap or correlation with all previous arXiv submissions. If enough of a match is found, a message could be sent to the submitter, listing the work(s) in which similarities have been detected. Should the submitter wish to proceed with their submission, the program would notify the editorial board and trigger an automatic review. The submitter would also be given the chance to explain that the flagged papers were not copied or that the copying was for some reason legitimate.
Such a system would address the problem of plagiarism only among papers published in arXiv, but apparently that would already be an improvement. And although plagiarists might opt to copy and translate from foreign-language journals, or simply alter wording enough to pass muster, making it more difficult will at least discourage the lazier offenders.
As journals should welcome eliminating plagiarism at the preprint stage before publication, they could support the effort by giving the arXiv site search access to their own full-text databases.

No comments:

Random Posts


  • Talk:2007 Plagiarism Ring Affair

    Blake StaceyJust one tiny quibble: "damage control" could suggest that METU is seeking to cover things up or spin them, which seems not to be the case at all, in fact my impression is that METU is handling this much more responsibly than most universities would do. Can I "be bold" in Wikipedia sense... READ MORE>>

  • 2007 Plagiarism Ring Affair - EUREKA

    In August of 2007, the technology-oriented website Ars Technica [1] revealed that the arXiv was withdrawing a set of seventeen physics papers due to plagiarism. These papers had been written by a group of graduate students at the Middle East Technical University (METU) in Ankara, Turkey. After detec... READ MORE>>

  • Massive Plagiarism Scandal - August 23rd, 2007

    Peter Woit From Ars Mathematica I learned about an article at Ars Technica describing a scandal involving plagiarism of theoretical physics papers by about 20 different people, some of them students at the Middle East Technical University in Ankara. Many of the papers were refereed and published i... READ MORE>>

  • Plagiarism at arXiv - Ars Mathematica

    A reader tipped me off to this article in Ars Technica about an egregious case of plagiarism uncovered at arXiv. At least two people, grad students at Middle East Technical University (METU), created papers in physics by splicing together existing papers. The plagiarism was uncovered by the faculty ... READ MORE>>

  • 65 admin withdrawals

    65 articles by a group of 14 authors have been withdrawn by the arXiv administration due to excessive reuse of text from articles by other authors. The withdrawn articles were submitted from late 2001 through mid 2007, mainly to gr-qc, and the vast majority (59) were submitted in 2005-2006. (See als... READ MORE>>

  • 38 Admin Withdrawals - arXiv

    38 articles have been withdrawn by the arXiv administration due to plagiarism. READ MORE>>

  • Academic accused of living on borrowed lines

    Nature 448, 632-633 (9 August 2007) | doi:10.1038/448632b; Published online 8 August 2007; Corrected 8 August 2007 There is a Correction (16 August 2007) associated with this document. READ MORE>>

.

.
.

Popular Posts