March 1, 2009

Borrowing words, or claiming them?

Editorial

Nature Immunology 10, 225 (2009)
doi:10.1038/ni0309-225

Journals are taking steps to stem of the practice of plagiarism.

Have you ever experienced a sense of déjà vu after reading a colleague's manuscript or researching a topic of interest? A paragraph or entire section sounds eerily familiar—too familiar, perhaps, because it is a word-for-word, verbatim (or nearly so, with a few synonyms tossed in) replication of another piece written by different authors. Or maybe a result or hypothesis is claimed to be 'novel' but in fact others have reported such findings and the previous work is not cited. Or the same data are presented in both earlier and subsequent publications from an author, but the later publication fails to acknowledge the fact that the data were included in the earlier work. Are any of these situations acceptable? In fact they are not. All three scenarios represent examples of what can be considered plagiarism.>>>


No comments:

Random Posts


  • Turkish Education Minister under Plagiarism Charges - Copy, Shake, and Paste

    Debora Weber-WulffThe Nature blog reports that the new Turkish Minister of Education, Ömer Dinçer, lost his title of professor in 2005 on the basis of plagiarism in a textbook published in his name. Turkish Council of Higher Education took back his professorship title, and Dinçer lost his legal appe... READ MORE>>

  • Contested plagiarism charge on new Turkish government

    Alison Abbott German politicians found guilty of plagiarism have seen their careers stumble. First came the forced resignation in March of the German defence minister Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg - the University of Bayreuth withdrew his PhD thesis after identifying extensive plagiarism. Other Ge... READ MORE>>

  • Doctoral Plagiarism Elsewhere - Copy, Shake, and Paste

    Plagiarized doctoral theses are not only to be found in Germany. Janet Stemwedel reports on Adventures in Ethics and Science on the case of chemist Bengü Sezen. She links to Chemical & Engineering News with a report on the disseration and three other papers. She quotes:The documents—an investiga... READ MORE>>

  • Promotion pressure fuels academic plagiarism - The Jacarta Post

    Several modus operandi of plagiarism: 1. Taking a research paper or article from a registered science journal, and copying it so that a lecturer can replace the name of the original author with his or her name. This plagiarized item will then be submitted along with their application for promotion.... READ MORE>>

  • From and to a very grey area

    EDITORIALEMBO reports (2011) 12, 479, Published online: 1 June 2011Howy Jacobs The scandal surrounding the former German Defence Minister Karl-Theodor von und zu Guttenberg, who resigned after facing accusations of plagiarism in parts of his doctoral thesis, raises troubling issues for all o... READ MORE>>

  • Copy and paste - NATURE

    Editorial Nature 473, Pages:419–420 , Date published:(26 May 2011)A slow university investigation into serious accusations of misconduct benefits no one.As retractions go, it may not look like a big deal. Earlier this month, a statistics journal decided to pull a little-cited 2008 paper on the socia... READ MORE>>

  • Is Academic Corruption on the Rise? - INSIDE HIGHER ED

    Ivan Pacheco  In Germany Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg, the former Minister of Defense, and Silvana Koch-Mehrin, a Vice-President of the European Parliament, resigned from their positions after plagiarism was discovered in each person’s doctoral dissertation. In the UK, the London School of Econom... READ MORE>>

.

.
.

Popular Posts