June 3, 2013

Journal retracts paper for plagiarism, but mathematician author doesn’t agree - Retraction Watch

The Journal of Mathematical Physics has retracted a paper by a prolific mathematician in Turkey who doesn’t agree that he plagiarized.
Here’s the notice, for “Homotopy perturbation method to obtain exact special solutions with solitary patterns for Boussinesq-like B(m,n) equations with fully nonlinear dispersion:”
The Editor wishes to retract the article1 because extensive passages in it, including results claimed to be new, are identical to material in a previously published paper by Yonggui Zhu. The author has not agreed to this retraction.
The paper has been cited four times, according to Thomson Scientific’s Web of Knowledge, including once by another paper by the author, and once by the retraction.
The author of the JMP paper, Ahmet Yildirim, earned his PhD in 2009 and has published an impressive 279 papers. We’ve asked why he didn’t agree to the retraction, and will update with anything we learn.

Random Posts


  • 10 Academic Frauds Who Had Everyone Fooled

    Admit it. We’ve all had that moment, deep into a school research project, where the realization hits that the neat hypothesis we had when we started working is not going to be borne out by the data. At that point, we are faced with two options: a) start over, instantly making all those hours alr... READ MORE>>

  • Fraud in the ivory tower (and a big one too)

    Freek VermeulenThe fraud of Diederik Stapel – professor of social psychology at Tilburg University in the Netherlands – was enormous. His list of publications was truly impressive, both in terms of the content of the articles as well as its sheer number and the prestige of the journals in which ... READ MORE>>

  • Journal Editors' Reactions to Word of Plagiarism? Largely Silence - THE CHRONICLE of HIGHER EDUCATION

    Tom BartlettLior Shamir was surprised to learn that one of his papers had been plagiarized. He was even more surprised to learn that it had been plagiarized, by his count, 21 times.But what really astonished him is that no one seemed to care.In July, Mr. Shamir, an assistant professor of computer sc... READ MORE>>

  • Breaking news: Prolific Dutch heart researcher fired over misconduct concerns - Retraction Watch

    Don Poldermans, a leading heart specialist, has been fired over concerns that he committed research misconduct. According to a report on the website DutchNews.nl:"Erasmus University in Rotterdam has sacked a professor in cardio-vascular medicine for damaging the institution’s academic integrity and ... READ MORE>>

  • Real scientists never report fraud

    Daniel LemireDiederik Stapel has been a psychology professor at major universities for the last ten years. He published well over 100 research papers in prestigious journals such as Science. Some of his research papers have been highly cited. He trained nearly 20 Ph.D. students.It was recently fired... READ MORE>>

  • The Fraud Who Fooled (Almost) Everyone - THE CHRONICLE of HIGHER EDUCATION

    Tom Bartlett  It’s now known that Diederik Stapel, the Dutch social psychologist who was suspended by Tilburg University in September, faked dozens of studies and managed not to get caught for years despite his outrageous fabrications. But how, exactly, did he do it?That question won’t be f... READ MORE>>

  • Diederik Stapel: The Lying Dutchman - The Washington Post

    By Joel AchenbachBig science news today out of the Netherlands: A top social scientist, Diederik Stapel, of Tilburg University, has been suspended after an investigation showed that he’s been fabricating his data for years. This may seem far away and esoteric in the extreme, but there’s collate... READ MORE>>

.

.
.

Popular Posts