May 8, 2012

Karachi University decides that plagiarism is not misconduct – drops charges - The k2p blog

It does seem that plagiarism is not considered a very serious matter at Universities in Pakistan.
Karachi University has found a novel way to drop plagiarism charges against 4 academics against whom plagiarism charges were established by an independent committee. They charged the academics with misconduct, took up the matter formally at a Syndicate meeting and then dismissed their own charges since misconduct does not apparently include plagiarism under the University Act!
Karachi University was founded in 1951 and is considered one of the top 3 universities in Pakistan.
If this sounds convoluted – it is as nothing compared to the twists and turns and charges and counter-charges in this 4 year old story. Prof Dr Jalaluddin Ahmed Noori, Prof Dr Najma Sultan, (her husband) Prof Dr Saeed Arayen and Zakia Bibi at the University of Karachi were accused of plagiarism and an investigation committee consisting of  two retired judges and one serving judge of the Sindh High Court found the plagiarism charge to be established. The University then – probably intentionally – charged them with  “misconduct  (and not plagiarism under the Higher Education Commission policy) as mentioned in the University Act”.
The University Syndicate has now dropped all charges – as reported by Dawn - >>>

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Random Posts


  • POGO to NIH: Stop Academic Ghostwriting Pollution - AHRP

    Project on Government Oversight (POGO) asked NIH Director to take a firm stance against ghostwriting by academics who receive taxpayer funded grants. POGO reminds the director of the National Institutes of Health (posted below) that taxpayers provide the NIH with $30 billion annually to fund ... READ MORE>>

  • Band of Academic-Plagiarism Sleuths Undoes German Politicians - THE CHRONICLE of HIGHER EDUCATION

    By Aisha LabiThe bad news keeps coming for the disgraced former German defense minister Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg, a once-rising star in his country's conservative party. On Wednesday the University of Bayreuth published the full report of its investigation into plagiarism in his 2006 doctoral diss... READ MORE>>

  • A good day for transparency

    Daniel Mietchen Some brief excerpts from today’s news on matters of plagiarized dissertations in Germany: >>> READ MORE>>

  • Research ethics: science faces On Fact and Fraud (Ars Technica)

    By JOHN TIMMER David Goodstein has a unique perspective on scientific fraud, having pursued a successful career in research physics before becoming the provost of Caltech, one of the world's premier research institutions. As an administrator, he helped formulate Caltech's first policy for scien... READ MORE>>

  • How journal editors can detect and deter scientific misconduct?

    Misconduct happens. So what can journal editors do find and prevent it? While we don’t claim to be experts in working on the other side of the fence — eg as editors — Ivan was flattered to be asked by session organizers at the Council of Science Editors to appear on a panel on the subject. He was j... READ MORE>>

  • Turkish testing official embroiled in new academic scandal

    A top educational official already embroiled in a controversy over an alleged cheating scandal on a national exam has been accused of academic plagiarism.According to the new claims, Professor Ali Demir, the chairman of Turkey’s Student Selection and Placement Center, or ÖSYM, plagiarized in an arti... READ MORE>>

  • Koch-Mehrin plagiarism charges thicken

    Silvana Koch-Mehrin, a leading light of Germany's Free Democratic Party and vice president of the European Parliament, has been accused of widely plagiarising her doctoral dissertation. A preliminary report released by the internet platform Vroniplag Wiki says 56 of the 201 pages of the MEP’s disse... READ MORE>>

.

.
.

Popular Posts