March 22, 2007

Reply (JHEP Journal)

----- Original Message -----
From: "JHEP Journal"
To: "ODTU Rektor"
Sent: Thursday, March 22, 2007 7:14 PM
Subject: Ethics Committee

Dear Professor Akbulut,

We have looked to your letter regarding plagiarism.

First of all, in matters of plagiarism it is the injured party that must take action. We are not involved in administering justice.

The authors of the paper in question seem to cite the articles from which they copy sentences or paragraphs. This weakens the case.

It may be that the paper should not have been published and that the refereerred. Unfortunately weak papers get sometimes published.This may happen when the work is in a rather minor subject or not in anactive and competitive field. If the results are oustanding or contradict well known physics this would not happen.

Therefore we fear that we cannot help you in this case.

Sincerely yours,
JHEP Journal

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Random Posts


  • Turkish mock conferences - Copy, Shake, and Paste

    I've been sent an article from Hürriyet, a Turkish daily newspaper, apparently about mock conferences and Turkish scientists. Google translate didn't do such a hot job on translating - anyone out there read enough Turkish to translate? Update 2012-06-18: Here's a translation, thank you to my anony... READ MORE>>

  • Mock Conferences - Copy, Shake, and Paste

    After being forced to remove pages from my blog dealing with what I called a "fake conference" and naming a name, the lawyer who tried (unsuccessfully) to discredit me at my university wrote a "thank you" note to the university stating what a fine person I am and then tried to get me to give her... READ MORE>>

  • "Die Wissenschaft" and plagiarism - Copy, Shake and Paste

    There's a bit of an absurd discussion running in Germany at the moment. The Süddeutsche Zeitung published a guest editorial by eight formerly important men in the German universities and scientific bodies. They make this clear by stating at the beginning of the editorial how important they were.... READ MORE>>

  • Massive Data Fraud in Chemistry - Copy, Shake, and Paste

    I have been sent a link on the Bengü Sezen case at Columbia University. Sezen is a chemist who was accused of massive data fraud, her case was under investigation by the Office of Research Integrity, a national organization dealing with scientific misconduct in the USA. At least 6 papers in w... READ MORE>>

  • List of Publishers : Beall’s List of Predatory Open-Access Publishers (Scholarly Open Access)

    Jeffrey BeallThis is a list of questionable, scholarly open-access publishers. I recommend that scholars not do any business with these publishers, including submitting articles, serving as editors or on editorial boards, or advertising with them. Also, articles published in these publishers’ journ... READ MORE>>

  • Plagiarism charge for Romanian minister - NATURE

     Alison AbbottRomania’s new government was thrown into turmoil last week after its education and research minister, Ioan Mang, was accused of extensive plagiarism in at least eight of his academic papers.The allegations first began circulating on 7 May, just hours after Prime Minister Victor Po... READ MORE>>

  • Romania's education minister caught in plagiarism row - The Sunday Times

    BUCHAREST (AFP) - Romania's new education minister is embroiled in a plagiarism row, forcing the prime minister to call for an investigation into claims that he copied swathes of foreign research works. This new copycat scandal in Europe comes after Germany's defence minister Theodor zu Guttenber... READ MORE>>

.

.
.

Popular Posts