March 21, 2007

Letter to Editors

From: "ODTU Rektor"
To: jhep-eo@jhep.sissa.it
Subject: Ethics Committee
Date: Wed, 21 Mar 2007 10:22:46 +0200

Dear Editors,

We are writing this message concerning a serious plagiarism case that we have come across with in a paper published by JHEP. First of all, we would like to express our disappointment in finding out that it was completely unnoticed by your Editorial Office and Refereeing Process. The details are provided in the pdf file we attached to this message with the relevant comments inserted in appropriate places.

The authors of this article are two graduate students of our University, Department of Physics, METU, Ankara. They have submitted 46 papers to the physics ArXiv, in 23 months and some of these have already been published by journals similar to yours. These people are going through an investigation led by the Ethics Committee of the University and will, most probaby be expelled from METU. However, it is noteworthy to mention that in their defence, they use the paper mentioned below as 'evidence' that their work is 'of the highest quality since it has been published by one of the leading journals of its area'. Needless to say, JHEP's integrity is in question here and we strongly believe that it is also JHEP's responsibility to react urgently and help us clear out this issue.

We are looking forward to hearing from at your earliest convenience.

Sincerely,
Prof.Dr. Ural Akbulut
President

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Random Posts


  • The Fraud Who Fooled (Almost) Everyone - THE CHRONICLE of HIGHER EDUCATION

    Tom Bartlett  It’s now known that Diederik Stapel, the Dutch social psychologist who was suspended by Tilburg University in September, faked dozens of studies and managed not to get caught for years despite his outrageous fabrications. But how, exactly, did he do it?That question won’t be f... READ MORE>>

  • Diederik Stapel: The Lying Dutchman - The Washington Post

    By Joel AchenbachBig science news today out of the Netherlands: A top social scientist, Diederik Stapel, of Tilburg University, has been suspended after an investigation showed that he’s been fabricating his data for years. This may seem far away and esoteric in the extreme, but there’s collate... READ MORE>>

  • Summation Letter on Plagiarism Case: Psychopathy requires legal entitlement, not logic or shame

    Zahir EbrahimThis is to summarize the situation since my discovery of the masterpiece of plagiarism in a tortuous system of willfully aiding and abetting the theft of intellectual property amidst lip-service to high piety, on Sept. 28, 2011.Over a hundred senior academics and senior civil servants o... READ MORE>>

  • Foreign student rule-breaking: culture clash or survival skills? -TIMES HIGHER EDUCATION

    Jon MarcusNorth American administrators call high rates of plagiarism 'tip of the iceberg'. Jon Marcus reportsGary Pavela remembers being surprised by the defiant reaction of a visiting student from China who he confronted over a clear-cut incident of plagiarism."But in my culture, we view it as hon... READ MORE>>

  • Retracted Science and the Retraction Index

    Ferric C. Fang, Editor in ChiefArturo Casadevall, Editor in ChiefR. P. Morrison, EditorInfection and Immunity Articles may be retracted when their findings are no longer considered trustworthy due to scientific misconduct or error, they plagiarize previously published work, or th... READ MORE>>

  • Science publishing: The trouble with retractions - NATURE

    A surge in withdrawn papers is highlighting weaknesses in the system for handling them.Richard Van NoordenThis week, some 27,000 freshly published research articles will pour into the Web of Science, Thomson Reuters' vast online database of scientific publications. Almost all of these papers will st... READ MORE>>

  • Paper mill websites increase in Turkey

    Çağla Pınar Tunçel - Hürriyet Daily NewsAcademics have decried the rise in the number of Turkish “paper mill” websites offering to write theses for students, yet company officials have defended their business, saying they are legal even as scholars warn of the ramifications.“Our company, which is ru... READ MORE>>

.

.
.

Popular Posts