March 21, 2007

Letter to Editors

From: "ODTU Rektor"
To: jhep-eo@jhep.sissa.it
Subject: Ethics Committee
Date: Wed, 21 Mar 2007 10:22:46 +0200

Dear Editors,

We are writing this message concerning a serious plagiarism case that we have come across with in a paper published by JHEP. First of all, we would like to express our disappointment in finding out that it was completely unnoticed by your Editorial Office and Refereeing Process. The details are provided in the pdf file we attached to this message with the relevant comments inserted in appropriate places.

The authors of this article are two graduate students of our University, Department of Physics, METU, Ankara. They have submitted 46 papers to the physics ArXiv, in 23 months and some of these have already been published by journals similar to yours. These people are going through an investigation led by the Ethics Committee of the University and will, most probaby be expelled from METU. However, it is noteworthy to mention that in their defence, they use the paper mentioned below as 'evidence' that their work is 'of the highest quality since it has been published by one of the leading journals of its area'. Needless to say, JHEP's integrity is in question here and we strongly believe that it is also JHEP's responsibility to react urgently and help us clear out this issue.

We are looking forward to hearing from at your earliest convenience.

Sincerely,
Prof.Dr. Ural Akbulut
President

No comments:

Random Posts


  • The Scientist: Me First!

    Glenn McGee The system of scientific authorship is in crisis. Two new rules could help make things right. READ MORE>>

  • Brane-world black holes and energy-momentum vector (removed from JHEP)

    Mustafa Salti et al JHEP12(2006)078 doi:10.1088/1126-6708/2006/12/078Mustafa Salti1, Oktay Aydogdu1 and Murat Korunur21 Department of Physics, Art and Science Faculty, Middle East Technical University, 06531, Ankara-Turkey2Department of Physics, Faculty of Art and Science, Dicle University, 21280, D... READ MORE>>

  • Turkish Professors Uncover Plagiarism in Papers Posted on Physics Server -THE CHRONICLE of HIGHER EDUCATION

    Aisha LabiDozens of academic papers containing apparently plagiarized work have been removed by moderators from arXiv, the popular preprint server where many physicists post their work before publication, Nature (subscription required) is reporting. According to the article, 67 papers by 15 physicis... READ MORE>>

  • Plagiarism at arXiv, and Nature journals' policies

    Maxine Clarke This week's Nature (449, 8; 2007) features a News story about a plaigiarism scandal involving more than a dozen theoretical physicists at four universities in Turkey. Almost 70 papers by 15 authors have been removed from the popular preprint server arXiv, where many physicists post th... READ MORE>>

  • Turkish physicists face accusations of plagiarism : News : NATURE

    Geoff Brumfiel AbstractScores of papers are removed from arXiv server. More than a dozen theoretical physicists at four universities in Turkey seem to be involved in a massive plagiarism scandal. Almost 70 papers by 15 authors have been removed from the popular preprint server arXiv, where many p... READ MORE>>

  • Cases of Plagiarism in Turkey

    Dear Colleagues: You may be already aware of a massive case of plagiarism uncovered recently in Turkey. You can find the details by linking to http://arxiv.org/new/removals07aug.html This news will no doubt be as disconcerting to you as it is to me. Plagiarism is not the bane of any one country ... READ MORE>>

  • Talk:2007 Plagiarism Ring Affair

    Blake StaceyJust one tiny quibble: "damage control" could suggest that METU is seeking to cover things up or spin them, which seems not to be the case at all, in fact my impression is that METU is handling this much more responsibly than most universities would do. Can I "be bold" in Wikipedia sense... READ MORE>>

.

.
.

Popular Posts