February 5, 2013

Düsseldorf Rescinds Doctorate of Education Minister Schavan - Copy, Shake and Paste

The dean of the Arts and Humanities faculty of the University of Düsseldorf announced on the evening of February 5, 2013, that the faculty board voted 13:2 that the dissertation of Annette Schavan is a plagiarism. They also voted 12:2:1 to rescind her doctorate.

There will be a flurry of press reports coming tomorrow, as Schavan is the Minister of Education and Research in Germany. Since her first academic degree was the doctorate, she now only has a high school diploma (Abitur). She can take the university to court within the next four weeks, if she chooses.

I will report more on the situation as it develops. The documentation of the plagiarism can be found at schavanplag. Current information from : Tagesschau - Spiegel - Süddeutsche Zeitung. Schavan's lawyers have announced that they will sue the university, according to Süddeutsche Zeitung.

The lawyers have published their reasoning for suing. They are mainly stating that information leaked out about the process, and that their suggestion of obtaining a second opinion was not followed [although one could see the schavanplag blog as a first opinion and the university one as a second opinion]. And she had so many pages and footnotes, that bit of plagiarism is not bad and was not intentional. It seems to me that they are not aware of the legal cases on plagiarism that determined just the opposite: Even a bit of plagiarism is not acceptable in a doctorate.

Random Posts


  • Koch-Mehrin plagiarism charges thicken

    Silvana Koch-Mehrin, a leading light of Germany's Free Democratic Party and vice president of the European Parliament, has been accused of widely plagiarising her doctoral dissertation. A preliminary report released by the internet platform Vroniplag Wiki says 56 of the 201 pages of the MEP’s disse... READ MORE>>

  • Keeping science fair

    Alex Holcombe Blind justice. A beautiful ideal! That the merits of a case are to be decided without regard to the identities of the parties involved or the size of their bank accounts. This is something science aspires to in evaluating manuscripts for publication. In fact it’s fundamental to the in... READ MORE>>

  • Plagiarism: Can It Be Stopped?

    G. Jay Christensen,  Business Communication Quarterly, published online 13 April 2011 PLAGIARISM CAN BE CONTROLLED, not stopped. The more appropriate question to ask is: What can be done to encourage students to “cheat” correctly by doing the assignment the way it was intended? I have lived my ... READ MORE>>

  • LETTER To the Editors' and Authors

    Irulandy Ponniah As a freelance reviewer for few journals based in India, I am often engrossed with the review of manuscripts being sent to me, especially, in the recent past. Understandably, the culture of increased manuscript submission was the consequence of governing b... READ MORE>>

  • Medical journals retract "unethical" research

    (Reuters) - The editors of 16 international medical journals have retracted "unethical" research carried out by a German doctor on drugs known as colloids, which boost blood volume in patients having surgery.>>> READ MORE>>

  • Ethics in Oncology: Lies, Big and Small, Matter - Relatively few scientific papers retracted

    Ronald Piana The Asco Post, Volume 2, Issue 5A recent study in the Journal of Medical Ethics found that 788 research papers published in medical journals between 2000 and 2010 were retracted for serious errors or falsified data.1,2 Study author Grant Steen, PhD, told The ASCO Post that U.S. scientis... READ MORE>>

  • Notes on a scandal

    EDITORIALNature Volume: 471, Pages: 135–136 , doi:10.1038/471135bHow an organism is affected by a particular gene mutation, as every geneticist knows, depends on that organism's genetic background. Although an obesity mutation introduced into one strain of mouse might produce a fat animal with diabe... READ MORE>>

.

.
.

Popular Posts