March 11, 2008

Plagiarism Accusation About Turkish Physicists

Turkiye Klinikleri J Med Ethics
Year: 2008 Volume: 16 Issue:1 

LETTER TO THE EDITOR
In an article published in Nature dated Sept 6, 2007, it was stated that nearly 70 articles of 15 scientists from 18 Mart, Dicle and Mersin universities have been removed from a popular preprint server by allegation of plagiarism.[1]
Some points in the article such as value-laden statements, generalizations, and that not taking into consideration of a system which urges academicians publishing with an orientalistic point of view in another language that they have not been educated appropriately, generated the thought of writing to the editor of Nature. I would like to share this letter, which was rejected by Nature, with our academic community, and sending your journal by hoping it to be ac cepted for publishing.

"Sir
Certain issues raised by Mr. Brumfiel’s article (“Turkish physicists face accusations of plagiarism” Nature 449, 8, 2007) must be addressed. It mustn’t be over looked that as yet there isn’t enough information to assess the situation thoroughly, and this essentially precludes the ability to make an ethical analysis of the situation. Although they contain some fallacies such as ad populum and non sequitor, some of the arguments made in their own defense by the accused academicians deserve to be considered seriously. For instance, they have publicly declared that some of the articles they have been accused of plagiarising were published after their work. Therefore language such as “allegedly” or “seem to be involved” is correct, not politically but factually. However, the sentence, “There are some cultures in which plagiarism is not even regarded as deplorable” is a counter-example. I’m not aware of any sociological research concerning this premise, perhaps it’s true; nevertheless, its inclusion makes the language value-laden. Since culture includes moral values which have been shaped and changed by various factors, it’s a mistake to discuss the moral atmosphere surrounding a certain scientific community without considering the factors which have shaped it, such as English barriers, as Mr. Smith mentioned (“Need to speak English puts burden on Asian scientists” Nature 445, 256, 2007), and local factors, such as those in Mr. Sarioglu’s formula: “They’re isolated, their English is bad, and they need to publish”. What Mr. Sarioglu didn’t include is ‘their work should interest Western editors’. If scientific work is assessed regarding editors’ interests per se, not the needs of a particular society, then publishing transforms to some kind of a price to pay, and end transforms to means.”

[1]. Brumfiel, G. Turkish physicists face accusations of plagiarism. Nature, 2007. 449(7158):8.

No comments:

Random Posts


  • Articles withdrawn from Open Access Database

    Debora Weber-Wulff I just ran across an article from 2007 about arXiv.org, one of the many Open Access databases, that withdrew 65 papers on General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology by 14 Turkish authors on the basis of the papers containing plagiarized material. One of the authors, a grad student a... READ MORE>>

  • Scientists informally intervene in cases of sloppy research - Ars Technica

    John TimmerMost people involved in scientific research are well aware of the big three ethical lapses: fabrication, falsification, and plagiarism. These acts are considered to have such a large potential for distorting the scientific record that governments, research institutions, and funding bodies... READ MORE>>

  • Prof Faces Plagiarism Charge

    Shanghai Daily A university professor is at the center of a plagiarism scandal after he was accused of copying from books written by Western researchers in his doctoral dissertation.Zhu Xueqin, a history professor at Shanghai University, denied the online accusation after a newspaper report about t... READ MORE>>

  • Journals step up plagiarism policing

    Nature 466, 167 (2010), doi:10.1038/466167a Cut-and-paste culture tackled by CrossCheck software. Declan Butler Major science publishers are gearing up to fight plagiarism. The publishers, including Elsevier and Springer, are set to roll out software across their journals that will scan submitted pa... READ MORE>>

  • Plagiarism pinioned

    NATURE/EDITORIAL  doi:10.1038/466159b Published online 07 July 2010 There are tools to detect non-originality in articles, but instilling ethical norms remains essentialIt is both encouraging and disheartening to hear that major science publishers intend to roll out the CrossCheck plagiarism-sc... READ MORE>>

  • Academic corruption undermining higher education: Yau Shing-tung

    By Guo Jiaxue (HK Edition) Updated: 2010-06-02 07:38 In China, the number of published papers in scientific journals are a critical criterion determining a researcher's professional standing and suitability for promotion. Edmond Tang / China Daily Even at China's best universities plagiarism and fa... READ MORE>>

  • A CULTURE OF PLAGIARISM

    Setiono Sugiharto The Jakarta PostPublication Date: 18-02-2010 A recent report on plagiarism implicating a professor from a private university in Indonesia has set a bad precedent for the integrity of academic honesty.Alleged to have published a plagiarised article in this paper, this senior schola... READ MORE>>

.

.
.

Popular Posts