November 8, 2012

Higher education: Call for a European integrity standard - NATURE


The global market for diplomas and academic rankings has had the unintended consequence of stimulating misconduct, from data manipulation and plagiarism, to sheer fraud. If incentives for integrity prove too hard to create, then at least some of the reasons for cheating must be obliterated through an acknowledgement of the problem in Europe-wide policy initiatives.
At the Second World Conference on the Right to Education this week in Brussels, we shall propose that the next ministerial communiqué of the Bologna Process in 2015 includes a clear reference to integrity as a principle. The Bologna Process is an agreement between European countries that ensures comparability in the standards and quality of higher-education qualifications.
Furthermore, the revised version of the European Standards and Guidelines for Quality Assurance, to be adopted by the 47 Bologna Process ministers in 2015, should include a standard that is linked to academic integrity (with substantive indicators), which could be added to all national and institutional quality-assurance systems.
We believe that an organization such as the Council of Europe has enforcement capabilities that can create momentum for peer pressure and encourage integrity. A standard-setting text, such as a recommendation by the Council of Ministers, or even a convention on this topic, would be timely given the deepening lack of public trust in higher-education credentials.
We do not expect that a few new international rules alone can change much. But we aim to create ways for institutions to become entrepreneurs of integrity in their own countries, as some models already exist (A. Mungiu-Pippidi and A. E. Dusu Int. J. Educ. Dev. 31, 532546; 2011).

Random Posts


  • Rampant cheating hurts China's research ambitions

    LIUZHOU, China (AP) — When professors in China need to author research papers to get promoted, many turn to people like Lu Keqian.Working on his laptop in a cramped spare bedroom, the former schoolteacher ghostwrites for professors, students, government offices — anyone willing to pay his fee, typic... READ MORE>>

  • Tokyo University researcher stripped of doctorate for plagiarism

    An assistant professor at the University of Tokyo has been stripped of his Ph. D. after he was found to have plagiarized his doctoral thesis, the university has announced. Anilir Serkan, 36, an assistant professor at the University of Tokyo's Faculty of Engineering, was found to have copied abou... READ MORE>>

  • Fraud, the h-index, and Pasternak

    Nicholas A. KotovACS Nano, 2010, 4 (2), pp 585–586DOI: 10.1021/nn100182y >>>> READ MORE>>

  • Publish or perish in China

    Nature 463, 142-143 (2010) , doi:10.1038/463142a Jane Qiu The latest in a string of high-profile academic fraud cases in China underscores the problems of an academic-evaluation system that places disproportionate emphasis on publications, critics say. Editors at the UK-bas... READ MORE>>

  • Scientific fraud: action needed in China - THE LANCET

    THE LANCET, Volume 375, Issue 9709, Page 94, 9 January 2010 EditorialOn Dec 19, 2009, editors at Acta Crystallographica Section Ealerted the scientific community to a disgraceful pattern of fraud involving papers they had published in 2007. At least 70 false crystal structures were reported—mainly... READ MORE>>

  • Plagiarism scandal grows in Iran

    Nature 462, 704-705 (2009) | doi:10.1038/462704a Investigation finds more cases of duplication in publications co-authored by ministers and senior officials.Declan ButlerEXCLUSIVE Nature has uncovered further instances of apparent plagiarism in papers co-authored by governmen... READ MORE>>

  • Analysis of retractions puts spotlight on academia

    Nicola Jones Nature Medicine 15, 1101 (2009) doi:10.1038/nm1009-1101 About half of the medical papers retracted over the past few decades were pulled because of misconduct rather than an innocent mistake, according to two new studies. And that fraction is on the increase. Yet although drug compa... READ MORE>>

.

.
.

Popular Posts